What Should Have Been, a poem
- Eric Benke

- Jul 12
- 2 min read
I wasn't ready to stop counting.
There was a college graduation I already pictured.
There was a first real job I never got to hear about.
Practicing your interview..
The phone call. The excitement in your voice "Dad, I got the job!".
Me pretending I wasn't already telling everyone I knew.
There was a call about a lease you needed me to look over.
A call about a car that made a noise you didn't trust.
A call just to ask if I thought you were making the right choice.
There was advice I never got to give (badly at times).
Money stuff. Relationship stuff.
The kind you'd nod along to and then do your own thing anyway.
I would've let you. I always would've let you.
There was a nursery I never painted.
Small shoes by the door.
I had grandchildren I was already spoiling.
Taught them nothing. Loved them anyway.
The ones who'd call me Pop, or Grandpa, or something
we would've decided on together, over a beer on the porch.
There was a whole life running past me
like a train I was supposed to catch later.
I was supposed to catch it later.
Instead I stand at the station
holding a ticket for a trip that isn't coming.
Milestones don't cancel quietly.
They just... don't arrive.
No graduation. No interview. No first job.
No 2 a.m. phone call asking how to fix a leaking sink.
No sleepless nights holding my grandchild in my arms
to ensure you get your rest.
I keep the version of the future where you're in it.
I don't know where else to put it.
So I write it down instead.
Not because it happened.
Because it should have.



Comments